Hey, HR Family!
In a significant development for the hospitality industry and HR professionals managing tipped employees, the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals has recently struck down the Department of Labor’s (DOL) tip credit final rule. This decision has important implications for how businesses calculate wages for tipped workers and could affect HR policies nationwide.
The DOL’s rule, which was introduced in 2021, aimed to clarify when employers could apply the tip credit to workers’ wages. Specifically, it stated that work directly supporting tip-producing activities could only be considered part of an employee’s tipped occupation if it wasn’t performed for a “substantial amount of time.”
However, the 5th Circuit found this rule to be inconsistent with the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) and “arbitrary and capricious” under the Administrative Procedure Act. The court’s main issue was that the rule drew an artificial line that discounted many core duties of an occupation simply because they didn’t directly produce tips.
For HR professionals, this ruling raises several important considerations:
- Wage Calculation: The overturned rule had set specific time limits (20% of weekly hours or continuous periods exceeding 30 minutes) for non-tipped work. With this guideline now invalidated, HR teams may need to reassess how they track and compensate for different types of work performed by tipped employees.
- Job Descriptions: The court’s decision emphasizes the importance of considering all core duties of a tipped position, not just those that directly produce tips. HR departments might want to review and update job descriptions to ensure they accurately reflect the full range of responsibilities.
- Training and Compliance: With this change in interpretation, it’s crucial to retrain managers and payroll staff on how to properly apply the tip credit under current law.
- Policy Updates: Companies may need to revise their policies regarding tipped employees to ensure compliance with this new interpretation of the FLSA.
While this ruling directly affects states under the 5th Circuit’s jurisdiction, it could have broader implications. Other circuit courts might consider this decision in similar cases, potentially leading to a nationwide reconsideration of the tip credit rule.
It’s worth noting that this decision overturned a previous ruling by a Texas district court that had sided with the DOL. This reversal highlights the complex and sometimes unpredictable nature of employment law.
As always, HR professionals should stay informed about these legal developments and consider consulting with legal experts to ensure their practices remain compliant with the latest interpretations of labor laws.
The hospitality industry and HR community will be watching closely to see if the DOL appeals this decision or if other circuits weigh in on similar cases. In the meantime, a flexible and attentive approach to managing tipped employees will be key for HR professionals navigating this changing legal landscape.
Be Audit-Secure!
Lisa Smith, SPHR, SCP
Note: This blog post is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice. Always consult with a legal professional for advice specific to your situation.
Here is what all you will get:
- Boss Calls™ – Access to EVERY Boss Call™ – Past & Future.
- HelpDesk for HR VAULT – Access to all 8 of our proprietary tools and applications to make your workday simple.
- Forms, Docs, Policies and Procedures Library – 700+ samples you can download and edit to fit your needs.
- U.S. ePoster Club – Download state, city, and local posters. Both required & recommended, for all 50 states & D.C.
- Same-day email support – Write to our team of SPHR and SCP professionals with all your HR questions.
