Clocking In on Clarity: The Blanco v. Samuel Case and the Importance of Understanding Overtime Laws

  • Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • Clocking In on Clarity: The Blanco v. Samuel Case and the Importance of Understanding Overtime Laws


The case “Blanco v. Samuel” revolves around Maria Blanco, a nanny and housekeeper employed by Anand Samuel and Dr. Lindsey Finch (the “Parents”). Blanco worked for the Parents for about three years, during which she worked 79 hours per week, including one 23-hour shift and four 14-hour overnight shifts. She filed a lawsuit seeking overtime compensation, which she believed she was entitled to under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA).


Key Points of the Case:

  1. Work Schedule and Compensation: Blanco worked long hours (79 per week) and was paid for all these hours. However, she believed she deserved overtime pay for 39 of these hours each week.
  2. Overtime Pay Exemption Dispute: The central legal question was whether Blanco was exempt from receiving overtime pay under the FLSA. The FLSA exempts live-in domestic service workers from overtime pay. The Parents argued that Blanco fell under this exemption because they considered her a live-in employee.
  3. Court’s Analysis: The court analyzed whether Blanco “resided” at the Parents’ house, as required for the exemption to apply. It considered factors like her work hours, where she spent her non-working hours, and her overall living arrangements.
  4. Court’s Decision: The court concluded that Blanco did not “reside” at the Parents’ house and therefore did not fall under the FLSA’s live-in service exemption. It found that she was entitled to overtime compensation for hours worked over 40 per week.


Lessons for Employers:

  1. Understand Overtime Rules: Employers must be familiar with labor laws, especially the FLSA, and understand who is entitled to overtime. Misclassifying employees can lead to legal disputes and financial penalties.
  2. Clear Employment Agreements: Have clear, written employment agreements that outline work hours, duties, and compensation. This clarity can prevent misunderstandings and legal issues.
  3. Record Keeping: Maintain accurate records of hours worked by employees. This practice is crucial for compliance with labor laws and can be vital evidence in legal disputes.
  4. Regular Reviews: Regularly review employment practices to ensure they comply with current labor laws. Laws and interpretations can change, and what was compliant one year may not be the next.
  5. Professional Advice: Seek advice from HR professionals or legal counsel on complex employment issues, especially for roles like live-in workers, where the laws can be more complicated.


In summary, the “Blanco v. Samuel” case underlines the importance of correctly classifying employees and understanding labor laws to avoid legal pitfalls and ensure fair treatment of employees.

Log in or Register to save this content for later.